Top 10 Cozy Horror Games for Halloween

Discover the 10 best cozy horror games that blend spooky Halloween atmosphere with approachable gameplay—perfect for getting into the Halloween spirit without losing sleep in October

Top 10 Cozy Horror Games for Halloween 2025 | LIST-EM. Article Image by 'Goodwill Games / Team17'

Boy do I have a treat for you this Halloween season! If you're like me and love the spooky vibes of October but don't necessarily want nightmares for weeks, then cozy horror games are absolutely your jam. These games nail that perfect balance between atmospheric chills and approachable gameplay—giving you all the Halloween feels without the psychological scarring.

As always, this list is based entirely on my tastes and what I've been obsessed with this October 2025. The cozy horror genre has absolutely exploded this year, and honestly, it's been pretty damn amazing watching indie developers create games that prove horror doesn't always need jump scares and gore to be effective. You are free to disagree with me on any of these picks, but I'm confident at least a few will become your new Halloween gaming traditions.

Alright, let's dive into the top 10 cozy horror games you should definitely check out this Halloween!

01 LITTLE NIGHTMARES III

Here we have one of October 2025's most anticipated releases that perfectly captures that cozy-spooky aesthetic we're going for. Little Nightmares III follows best friends Low and Alone as they navigate the creepy-yet-gorgeous world of the Nowhere, and boy is it breathtaking.

The game absolutely nails the atmospheric horror vibe with its stunning hand-drawn animation style and haunting environments. What makes this a cozy horror gem is the emphasis on teamwork and puzzle-solving rather than combat, so you're getting all the Halloween ambiance without constant stress. Playing co-op with a friend makes it even better—you can experience the spooky journey together while hoisting each other over obstacles and solving environmental puzzles.

The art direction is top-notch, with that signature Little Nightmares blend of Burton-esque creepiness and strangely beautiful design. Definitely worth experiencing this October.

02 BYE SWEET CAROLE

Man, talk about gorgeous visuals! This narrative-horror game set in early 1900s Britain has some of the most stunning hand-drawn animation I've seen this year. You play as young Lana Benton searching for her best friend Carole Simmons while uncovering dark secrets about the Bunny Hall orphanage.

What's really cool about Bye Sweet Carole is how it weaves historical context (the women's suffrage movement) into its spooky narrative. The game leans heavily into atmospheric dread rather than cheap scares, creating this wonderfully eerie Victorian-era mystery that feels perfect for cozy fall gaming sessions.

The chilling story combined with the absolutely breathtaking art style makes this one of my favorite cozy horror experiences of 2025. It's like playing through an interactive Tim Burton film, and I mean that in the best possible way.

03 THE SÉANCE OF BLAKE MANOR

Honestly, this detective mystery puzzler set in 1897 Ireland is exactly what I needed this Halloween. You're investigating the disappearance of Evelyn Deane in a remote manor hotel, and let me tell you, the supernatural vibes are immaculate.

What makes The Séance of Blake Manor so cozy-horror perfect is the emphasis on investigation, interviewing guests, and puzzle-solving. You're not running from monsters—you're piecing together clues and interrogating suspects in a beautifully atmospheric setting. That being said, supernatural forces are definitely at play, adding just enough spookiness to keep things interesting.

The time management mechanic adds strategic depth since every action advances the day, so you need to be thoughtful about your investigation approach. Released just this week in October 2025, it's the perfect Halloween game for mystery fans who want spooky atmosphere without jump scares.

04 INSCRYPTION

Here's a personal favorite that still holds up amazingly well. This roguelike deck-builder psychological horror game is absolutely one-of-a-kind. You're trapped playing a dangerous card game against a mysterious shadowy figure with menacing white eyes, and honestly, it's as addictive as it sounds.

What elevates Inscryption to cozy horror status is the strategic gameplay loop—you're constantly unlocking new cards, solving puzzles, and exploring the cabin between rounds. Sure, there's psychological horror elements, but the deck-building mechanics are so engaging that the scares become part of the fun rather than overwhelming.

The meta-narrative gets wonderfully weird as you progress, with twists that genuinely surprised me. It blends horror, strategy, and humor in ways I didn't think possible. Definitely recommended for anyone who wants something unique this Halloween season.

05 STRANGE HORTICULTURE

Alright, this one truly embodies that autumn cozy-horror aesthetic. You run an occult plant shop in a forgotten place shrouded in mystery, and honestly, it's one of the most atmospheric games I've played.

The gameplay revolves around identifying mysterious plants, solving puzzles, and uncovering dark secrets about the town and its residents. What's really cool is how the game nails that rainy-day-with-tea vibe while maintaining genuine creepiness through its occult themes and unsettling discoveries.

The autumn atmosphere is absolutely perfect—think candlelit shops, mysterious flora, and foggy small-town mysteries. There's even a cat companion! Strange Horticulture proves that horror doesn't need violence or jump scares to be effective. Much like a good mystery novel, it builds dread through atmosphere and investigation.

06 GLOOMY EYES

Boy, the visual style of this one is something special. This narrative VR experience (also playable without VR) tells a beautiful yet eerie story about a world where the sun hasn't risen in years and humans hide underground while zombie-like creatures roam above.

What makes Gloomy Eyes wonderfully cozy-horror is the storybook presentation narrated by Colin Farrell. The stop-motion animation style creates this gorgeous, melancholy atmosphere that's spooky without being scary. You're experiencing a touching story about love and hope in dark times, wrapped in Halloween-appropriate aesthetics.

The art direction alone makes this worth playing, with that handcrafted diorama look that feels like exploring a Tim Burton pop-up book. Perfect for a chill October evening when you want something atmospheric and story-driven.

07 COZY GROVE

Now here's a game that puts the "cozy" in cozy horror! This life-sim game has you playing as a Spirit Scout helping ghosts on a haunted island, and honestly, it's adorable. Think Animal Crossing meets gentle ghost stories.

What's really cool is the hand-drawn art style that transforms from black-and-white to vibrant color as you help spirits find peace. The gameplay loop involves fishing, crafting, decorating, and most importantly, listening to ghost stories and solving their unfinished business.

The Halloween vibes are perfect without being scary—you're dealing with friendly (if troubled) ghosts in a beautifully illustrated world. Thanks to the real-time gameplay that unfolds day-by-day, it's perfect for daily October check-ins. Definitely a recommended watch—er, play—for anyone who wants spooky comfort gaming.

08 PIPKIN

Here we have a pixelated JRPG creature collector that absolutely nails that cozy fall/Halloween aesthetic. Set in the town of New Haven, Pipkin lets you collect over 60 creatures while exploring an autumn-themed world that feels perfectly seasonal.

What really stands out is the robust battle system with 250 moves, 15 elemental types, and 4 classes. This isn't some shallow collector—it's a meaty RPG that respects your time by putting pacing in your hands. The Halloween atmosphere is consistent throughout without being overwhelming.

The pixelated art style is gorgeous, with that retro JRPG charm that works wonderfully for the spooky-cozy vibe. If you loved games like Pokémon but want something with more Halloween spirit, Pipkin is definitely worth checking out this October.

09 LUIGI'S MANSION 3

Okay sure, this one's not brand new, but honestly, it remains one of the absolute best cozy horror experiences you can play, especially during Halloween season. Luigi exploring a haunted hotel with his trusty Poltergust is gaming perfection.

What makes Luigi's Mansion 3 so damn good is the perfect balance of spooky atmosphere and Nintendo charm. The game is legitimately creepy at times with its haunted hotel setting and ghost encounters, but it's always approachable and often hilarious. Luigi's reactions alone are entertainment gold.

The gameplay is wonderfully polished with creative boss fights, excellent puzzle design, and gorgeous visuals that showcase each hotel floor's unique theme. Playing through this during October has become a yearly tradition for me, and I absolutely recommend it to anyone with a Nintendo Switch.

10 NIGHT IN THE WOODS

Let's be real—this game perfectly captures autumn vibes like nothing else. You play as Mae, a college dropout returning to her dying rust-belt hometown, and what starts as a meditation on small-town America becomes genuinely unsettling.

What elevates Night in the Woods is the gorgeous fall scenery combined with gradually building creepiness. You're exploring your hometown, reconnecting with friends, and uncovering mysteries that get progressively darker. The art style is absolutely breathtaking with constant autumn aesthetics.

The narrative is superb, balancing humor, melancholy, and genuine spookiness in ways that feel authentic. That being said, the Halloween vibes come more from atmosphere and mystery than overt horror. It's perfect for anyone who wants seasonal gaming that makes you think and feel while maintaining that cozy-spooky balance.

As always, this list reflects my personal preferences, and you're completely free to disagree! The cozy horror genre has truly come into its own this year, giving us wonderful options for Halloween gaming that don't require iron nerves or tolerance for gore. These games prove that atmospheric storytelling, beautiful art direction, and thoughtful gameplay can be just as effective—if not more so—than traditional horror mechanics.

Whether you're into detective mysteries, creature collecting, deck-building strategy, or narrative adventures, there's absolutely something here for everyone this Halloween 2025. What do you think? Let me know down below!

Top 10 Cozy Horror Games for Halloween 2025 | LIST-EM. All images featured on list-em.com are the copyright & property of their respective owners. Images by List-em or its creator are clearly stated. But, if there is anything on List-em or its affiliated sites, that has been improperly credited, please email us at [email protected]. So, if you have any concerns about an image, please let us know if you would like the image to be correctly attributed or removed and, we shall do so promptly and courteously.